My Premier League Worst XI of the Season So Far. Who Makes Yours?

Having written my best Prem XI of the season so far, it’s only natural to do the opposite.
So here’s my worst team of the campaign in its first few months…
Goalkeeper and Defence
Gianluigi Donnarumma | GK | Manchester City
By the standards the Italian has set for himself, he’s starting to struggle at the Etihad. It doesn’t help that the champions have a keeper who wins his team points with his saves. Enzo Maresca doesn’t have that at the moment.
His goalie has never been the most comfortable with the ball at his feet, and that stands out now that his back four have lost confidence in possession. Now, though, the 27-year-old is conceding goals he shouldn’t be. That’s carried over to the international stage.
Diogo Dalot | LB | Manchester United
Harsh on the Portuguese?
It’s not his fault his manager asked him to play out of position, but it’s been a disaster.
At times it’s meant Noussair Mazraoui has had to cover on the right, meaning United have started far too many games with two full-backs not in their natural roles. For me, that decision was one of the things that cost Michael Carrick his job.
The lack of positional awareness and the errors from the 27-year-old have been surreal.
Lisandro Martínez | CB | Manchester United
Fans, managers, pundits and teammates understand a player struggling for form and confidence. But if you’re going to publicly criticise the signings brought in, you need to make sure your own performance levels are high.
The irony of the Argentine criticising his employers’ recruitment policy is that, before and since, I’ve seen the 28-year-old make more errors than any of his peers.
There will be Red Devils supporters who agree with what the defender said about their director of football, but what Michael Carrick needed was a World Cup winner to lead and set standards for a struggling back four.
Marc Guéhi | CB | Manchester City
There’s a different pressure playing for Man City compared with Crystal Palace. Not everyone can cope with the demands of a game every few days when every game feels like a must-win.
There were signs in last season’s title run-in that Guéhi was starting to make individual errors, and that’s carried over to this campaign.
In particular, it’s apparent how uncomfortable he is playing out from the back. The 26-year-old didn’t need to worry about that at Selhurst Park.
Daniel Muñoz | RB | Nottingham Forest
The Colombian hasn’t been a disaster at the City Ground, but there was simply more expectation after his move in a deal worth up to £22 million.
He’s one of the few at Forest who can’t hide behind needing time to adapt to a new manager’s approach, because the defender followed Oliver Glasner from Selhurst Park.
The 30-year-old might be waiting for his teammates to get to grips with the tactics, because so far he’s not getting into attacking areas like he did with the Eagles or at the World Cup. He’s yet to form an understanding down the right in Nottingham like the one he had with Sarr in South London.

(Photo by Justin Setterfield/Getty Images)
Midfield and Attack
Bruno Fernandes | CM | Manchester United
The Portuguese midfielder’s current struggles show how quickly the sport can change. Only a few months ago he was picking up individual awards. If anyone had said then that by November some United fans would be suggesting the time had come to sell their star man, few would have believed you.
There have probably been midfielders who’ve played worse this season, but bonus points were awarded for a post-match interview in Italy.
As with Martínez, many will agree with the captain’s assessment of the club. But this was when Michael Carrick needed his skipper to lead the dressing room more than ever. Instead of setting an example by taking responsibility, the man meant to lead the squad was questioning the manager’s tactics in the press.
There’s still no agreement on a new contract, either.
Sandro Tonali | CM | Tottenham
This was always going to happen the moment Spurs agreed to pay £100 million for the midfielder.
I understood their recruitment policy. They were willing to pay over the odds to put other clubs off making a bid. Yet there are still certain expectations if that’s your price tag!
For that amount of money, fans expect you to be the man everyone relies on when things get tough. The difference between success and failure. The one to take responsibility.
Has the Italian ever shown he has the personality to be that person? He certainly hasn’t yet in North London.
Jack Grealish | LM | Everton
Another player who makes this list based on his choices off the pitch.
It’s not like David Moyes is spoilt for creative options, so the fact he left one of his few flair players out for three games following a breach of club discipline tells you how seriously the Toffees took it.
It’s frustrating because the point of this loan spell was for the 31-year-old to prove some of his doubters wrong. Before his injury last season, he was exciting the blue half of Merseyside. He’s currently making a mess of this spell.
Florian Wirtz | CM | Liverpool
When a player moves from abroad, it’s understandable that they might need time to settle into a new culture on and off the pitch.
Over a year is long enough, and yet Liverpool can’t get the best out of someone whose deal was worth around £115 million.
It’s not like the German is taking responsibility in games and just getting his final ball wrong or lacking quality in the final third. Games simply pass him by.
The 23-year-old has shown little personality. There have been games this season where the Reds have struggled to register enough shots on target. When that’s happening, it means something is wrong with your creative midfielder.
Sávio | RM | Tottenham
Another player Spurs appear to have overpaid for, as things stand.
The assumption was that his output in England had been poor because he hadn’t been given enough opportunities at the Etihad, and that would change with the Brazilian starting more often in North London.
If anything, he’s simply providing evidence of why he wasn’t trusted to play more often in Manchester.
The 22-year-old has yet to make much of an impact in the league for Tottenham, which isn’t good enough for a talent who cost an initial £75 million!
He’s wasteful in the final third, his final ball is poor and he loses possession too often.
Still young enough to improve, though?
Gonzalo García | ST | Fulham
You can understand that a young forward from Spain might need time to adjust to a more physical style of football and a new culture off the pitch. The bigger concern is the nature of the chances the 22-year-old is missing. That’s cost Fulham massive points.
The youngster hasn’t scored or assisted since the opening weekend of the season. I’m not a huge fan of expected goals as a stat, but he’s scored fewer than you’d expect from the chances he’s had.
He’s being brought off earlier and earlier in games, even when his team need a goal.
The Cottagers’ survival could be decided by small details. Spending around £40 million on a striker with one goal in 10 Prem games could be the difference between staying up and going down.
Let me know yours in the comments peeps.
Dan Smith
Who’s been the biggest letdown for you so far, and who in Dan’s XI deserves a bit more patience?
Join the conversation in the comments below. _____________________________________________________________________________________________ ADMIN COMMENT
So here are some simple rules which I must insist commenters follow….
You agree not to give any personal abuse to other Arsenal fans. Everyone is allowed to hold their own opinions even if you disagree with them. It COSTS NOTHING TO BE POLITE TO OTHER ARSENAL FANS.
CALLING ALL ARSENAL FANS! Anyone who would like to contribute an Article or Video opinion piece on JustArsenal, don’t hesitate to get in touch with us through this link…