slide-icon

What success at Chelsea should look like with fans firmly divided

doc-content image

After 10 games, Xabi Alonso’s Chelsea currently find themselves fifth in the Premier League table.

By the end of the season, that could be enough for them to qualify for the Champions League. If not, they are only two points behind Liverpool in fourth, which means the team still have a great chance of finishing in the top four.

But is a top four or top-five finish enough for this campaign to go down as a successful one? Not every football fan would agree.

What are Chelsea’s expectations this season?

While Chelsea have received some criticism this season, one supporter on TalkingPoints does not think they are actually struggling because fifth place is where they should be.

The Chelsea board would not disagree. Again, fifth place could be a Champions League spot again, and securing one is Chelsea’s ultimate objective.

Featured comment

seanfisher

Might be a hot take but I don’t think they’re struggling *that* badly. They’re 5th in the PL and still adapting to a new manager with a very refreshed squad. There has been inconsistency and some poor results, but no need to panic

Join the conversation →

It was recently reported that qualifying for the Champions League is what the Chelsea board expect from Alonso. That seems to be the bare minimum.

Not everyone believes that will be good enough. Another fan thinks that aiming for fifth shows just how much Chelsea have declined.

chillout

If 5th is good enough, then how mighty Chelsea has fallen.

Chelsea should be challenging for the title

You cannot blame anyone for demanding more from Chelsea. After the kind of money the club have spent, they should be challenging for the Premier League title.

This summer alone, BlueCo spent €407.4m on transfers, which is roughly £340m, according to Transfermarkt. Since Clearlake Capital and their former partner Todd Boehly bought Chelsea in 2022, the Blues have been the biggest spenders in the country.

Yet their highest finish in the Premier League has only been fourth. They have only been the fourth best team in England despite significantly outspending everyone else.

*Also via Transfermarkt

With that kind of backing, Chelsea should be competing for the title. Instead, they find themselves miles behind Arsenal, finishing 33 points below their London rivals last season. This is a team who used to finish 33 points above others on their way to title glory themselves. Their decline is not spoken about enough.

TalkingPoints

We have graded some of Xabi Alonso's key roles at Chelsea so far. What grade would you give him and why?

doc-content image

Why Chelsea aren’t challenging for the title

So, why exactly are Chelsea not competing at the very top of the Premier League table despite outspending Arsenal and even Manchester City on occasions? Well, Chelsea have not used their cash well. It is as simple as that.

Their transfer strategy has seen them sign dozens of young players with potential but not the ability to make an impact right away. The club’s sporting directors have assembled a young and inexperienced squad who are not ready for a title charge.

The likes of Jamie Gittens and Alejandro Garnacho are great examples of why Chelsea have not been in the title race recently and how money does not guarantee success.

Chelsea paid almost £100m combined to sign Gittens and Garnacho from Borussia Dortmund and Manchester United respectively. A year on, Chelsea are already open to letting Gittens go, while Garnacho has already been allowed to join Aston Villa on loan in a deal that could become a permanent move.

Gittens has had injuries and failed to score a single goal in the English top flight last season, while Garnacho managed just one in 24 games.

Chelsea can have all the money they want, but if that money is only spent on young talent who might, might become world-beaters one day, it is going to take a long time for them to become a serious team again.

Chelsea need more than top four to have a successful season

Chelsea should always be aiming for a top-four finish in the Premier League, but that alone is not enough. Out of the Carabao Cup, they now have to aim for FA Cup success to go with Champions League qualification.

This should be the bare minimum for a club of Chelsea’s stature, history and ambition. Qualifying for the Champions League is essential, but competing for silverware should be just as important. Ultimately, finishing a season trophyless cannot be considered a success by Chelsea’s standards. This is a club built on winning trophies, competing at the highest level and setting high expectations.

Progress and building a team for the future is important, but it should never become an excuse for lowering the standards that Chelsea should be striving to meet.

Premier LeagueUEFA Champions LeagueChelseaLiverpoolArsenalManchester CityXabi AlonsoJamie Gittensfootball